We recently sat down with Camille Fetter, Founder & CEO of Talentfoot, the top executive search firm in the US, to talk about a hiring market where many leadership roles are filled without a public posting. Talentfoot has a 98% client success rate across 2,500+ placements, recruiting sales, marketing, technology, HR, and accounting and finance leaders for lower-middle market and PE companies nationwide. Camille shared what senior candidates should know about how those searches work, and how to make sure a recruiter can find them.
Q: Why are so many senior roles never posted publicly?
Camille Fetter: Many executive searches are confidential because the hiring decision itself contains information a company is not ready to disclose.
The most common example is a planned leadership change. An incumbent may still be in the role while the board or executive team quietly evaluates a successor, restructures responsibilities, or plans an internal transition. In those situations, confidentiality allows the company to manage the change thoughtfully without creating unnecessary uncertainty for employees, customers, investors, or the executive involved.
But replacement searches are only one reason. Companies also use confidential search when they are creating a new leadership position tied to an unannounced strategy, entering a new market, preparing for an acquisition or transaction, building a capability competitors do not yet know about, or making changes to the organizational structure that have not been communicated internally.
There is also a competitive dimension. Advertising that you are replacing a CRO, CTO, CMO, or other critical executive can signal vulnerabilities or strategic priorities to competitors. In some cases, it can create opportunities for competitors to approach customers, employees, or key partners before the company is ready to communicate the change.
That is why some of the most consequential executive opportunities never reach a public job board. They are handled through targeted search, where a firm can discreetly identify and engage a small group of qualified leaders while protecting the confidentiality of both the company and the candidates involved.
Q: If a role is never posted, how does a search firm find candidates?
Camille Fetter: Through targeted headhunting, market mapping, and deep functional networks.
A strong executive search does not begin by waiting for candidates to apply. It begins by defining what success in the role actually requires, then mapping the market for leaders with the right combination of experience, scale, industry exposure, leadership profile, and track record.
From there, recruiters proactively identify and approach the executives who best match that mandate, including people who are performing well in their current roles and have no reason to be searching job boards. That is why so much of the executive talent market is passive.
Relationships still matter, particularly because experienced recruiters know who has done what, where strong leaders sit, and how reputations have developed over time. But relationships are not a substitute for search discipline. The best firms combine market intelligence, research, referrals, prior candidate relationships, and direct outreach to build a targeted slate of candidates, rather than relying on whoever happens to be visible or actively looking.
For executives, the implication is important: you do not need to be actively job searching to be considered for a significant opportunity. But your experience, accomplishments, and market reputation need to be discoverable enough for a search firm to identify you when the right mandate arises.
Q: When an executive resume reaches Talentfoot, what do you look for first?
Camille Fetter: Results tied to business outcomes: revenue grown, pipeline created, margin and ROI improved, teams built. Then scope: budget, headcount, and reporting line. A CMO reporting on impressions loses to one who can show pipeline and customer acquisition cost. A CFO who managed the close loses to one who drove capital allocation and presented to the board.
Q: What happens after a recruiter reaches out?
Camille Fetter: At Talentfoot, finalists complete a structured interview and assessment process, including Hogan leadership assessments, before we present them to a client as Talentfoot Certified Candidates. Your resume opens the door. How you explain your decisions and results in those conversations decides whether you move forward.
Q: What is the biggest resume mistake you see at the executive level?
Camille Fetter: Listing responsibilities instead of results. "Oversaw a team of 40" tells me the size of the job, not how well you did it. The second is waiting until you are job hunting to update anything. Confidential searches move quickly, and the candidate with a current resume that lists quantifiable results gets the first call.
Q: What is your advice for executives who are happy where they are?
Camille Fetter: Stay in touch with one or two recruiters who specialize in your function, and keep your story current. You do not need to be looking to be ready.
Talentfoot is a boutique executive search firm founded by Camille Fetter, with a 98% client success rate and 2,500+ placements across sales, marketing, technology, HR, and accounting and finance leadership. The firm offers retained, engaged, and contingency search models tailored for every client's size, stage, and hiring objectives backed with an industry leading guarantee. Interested employers and executives can speak with one of Talentfoot's search experts.
Written by
Madison Norton
Resume Expert & VP Marketing
Madison is the VP Marketing and General Manager at VisualCV. He's a seasoned marketing leader, resume writing and career marketing expert and now helping people grow their own career marketing strategies to build a career they love.